SIREN Report Highlights Knowledge Gaps on Social Screening

June 23, 2022
Little is known about the prevalence of social screening across U.S. healthcare settings, and there is not yet a clear strategy for improving national prevalence estimates, study finds

A new report from the Social Interventions Research and Evaluation Network (SIREN) at the University of California San Francisco identified several knowledge gaps that should be addressed to inform efforts to implement and scale up social screening practices in the U.S. healthcare system.

Emilia H. De Marchis, M.D., M.A.S., an assistant professor in the Department of Family & Community Medicine at UCSF, is the lead author on “State of the Science of Screening in Healthcare Settings, which was supported by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

The report examined and synthesized the existing literature on social screening in healthcare settings and noted that while there has been quite a bit of research done, “it is not yet impressively rigorous. Many of the studies on social screening are qualitative, include small sample sizes, and/or lack comparison groups."

For instance, when it comes to the basic question of how many people are getting screened, the authors say “we know relatively little about the prevalence of social screening across U.S. healthcare settings and there is not yet a clear strategy for improving national prevalence estimates. Without these, it will be difficult to understand the impacts of investments intended to increase screening. Future prevalence assessments will need to address the lack of both shared prevalence measures and denominator reporting.”

Patient perspectives on screening: The authors note that although research suggests that patients and patient caregivers generally find social screening to be acceptable, “relatively little research has explored or compared the perspectives of racially, ethnically, and linguistically diverse patient populations.” They added that several studies surface patients’ concerns about the collection/ storage/sharing of social data.

Healthcare team perspectives on screening: Research tends to support the idea that healthcare professionals generally believe activities related to patients’ social needs are within the scope of practice of healthcare and can strengthen relationships with patients, the authors note. “Education/training and screening program participation help to reduce many provider concerns about implementing social screening, with the exception of concerns about clinic workflow and the availability of social services.”

Implementation best practices:  The authors find that in the published literature to date, there are no consistently reported differences in screening reach by race/ethnicity, although two studies found lower reach in Spanish-language speaking patients. Few studies have rigorously examined differences across studies on screening disclosure by factors such as healthcare setting, workforce conducting screening, framing for screening, modality of screening (in-person interview, telehealth interview, tablet [including chatbot]). Telehealth did not substantively decrease screening reach.

The authors expressed hope that surfacing the literature gaps will prompt a commitment to learning more about social screening and social care interventions in coming years. “The ‘thousand flowers blooming’ approach that has heretofore characterized screening approaches, including around tool selection, workforce, and modality for screening, presents us with myriad opportunities to learn about what works and for whom,” they wrote. “As those opportunities continue expanding, it is incumbent on healthcare stakeholders to learn from them, ensure they involve relevant data collection (including on race, ethnicity, and language of participants), invest in data analysis, and finally, share findings.”

Sponsored Recommendations

How Digital Co-Pilots for patients help navigate care journeys to lower costs, increase profits, and improve patient outcomes

Discover how digital care journey platforms act as 'co-pilots' for patients, improving outcomes and reducing costs, while boosting profitability and patient satisfaction in this...

5 Strategies to Enhance Population Health with the ACG System

Explore five key ACG System features designed to amplify your population health program. Learn how to apply insights for targeted, effective care, improve overall health outcomes...

A 4-step plan for denial prevention

Denial prevention is a top priority in today’s revenue cycle. It’s also one area where most organizations fall behind. The good news? The technology and tactics to prevent denials...

Healthcare Industry Predictions 2024 and Beyond

The next five years are all about mastering generative AI — is the healthcare industry ready?